Quality Professional Service, With 15+ Years of Experience

Upcoming Events

Arrowhead Tax Service is a locally owned business which has been in the city of New Carlisle since 2015

Michael Maxwell


Michael received his accounting degree from Clark State Community College.

After working over 10 years with Liberty Tax Service as tax preparer and marketing manager, he started his own company, Arrowhead Tax Service, in New Carlisle, Ohio in 2015.

Both of Michael’s parents John and Barbara Maxwell taught at Tecumseh Local Schools for over 30 years.

Giving Back 

We are committed to making a difference in the community. We will give a $10 donation for every paid tax return to a local nonprofit or charity. We also have sponsored many Baseball and Softball teams within the community. Michael has worked with the New Carlisle Farmer’s Market each year. We have worked with and sponsored other organizations like the Heritage of Flight and more. 

Client Testimonials

I started an In-home daycare in 2017. I had no idea what i was doing with my taxes come 2018. I got everything together that i could possibly think of and scheduled an appointment at Arrowhead Tax Services. Taxes got done quickly and had my return back in no time with no issues. Very easy to work with and supports the community. Went to Arrowhead again in 2019. Highly recommended.

Laurie Bowers

We have been using Michael at Arrowhead Tax Service for our personal taxes. After opening up our own business this past year, we knew that we could trust Michael to handle both our personal and business taxes. When using Arrowhead we receive knowledgeable, reliable, and affordable services. We highly recommend Arrowhead Tax Service!
Katie Waymire

We have used Arrowhead Tax Service many years and have called throughout the year with tax questions. Very reassuring to have a tax service that Is there for you year- round to give you competent, friendly service. You’re the best Arrowhead!
Randy Allison

Professional and Trustworthy! We trust Mike to do our taxes and more every year. Highly recommend Arrow Head Tax Service.
Evelyn Mazzone

Fast and friendly. They've earned a customer. I highly recommend them.
William Richardson

We have been with same account for years and due to retirement time needed to change; Michael was pleasant and made the change wonderfully easy; we will be back next year.
Tammy Leatherman

Very knowledgeable and wonderful 1 on 1 customer service. He works with u and makes u feel like there's an actual person working with u instead of a robot! (Which I DEFINITELY appreciate) Can't express my gratitude enough for his kindess and awesome service. 💯👏

Melanie Grimm

For the past 2 years, Michael has done my taxes for me. I've had multiple accountants over the years.. but no more of that!! He will continue to be my go-to for as long as possible!!! After I schedule my appt w him, he let's me know exactly what info and paperwork he needs. During my apot, he goes over everything w me and he thoroughly answers any and all of my questions; which I love!! One thing that I truly admire and love about him and how he runs his business.. is with every tax return he files, he also donates to a local charity.. OF YOUR CHOICE from his provided long list of options. Of course, I always go for anything cause that's animal related!! He is truly a great human and the best accountant that I've been to!! I highly recommend you making an appt w him!!!

Savanah Akers

Getting my taxes done at Arrowhead was fast and affordable.

Bill Miller

My experience with arrowhead is beyond bliss. Year after year, Michael takes fantastic care of me. In a timely manner! 10/10! Recommend

Brandon Helton

Free Estimate or Consultation

Set Up a Free Estimate or Consultation Today!

Call us today for a free Tax Preparation estimate or a free consultation for our Payroll and Accounting Services.